AtlanticPulse

National perspective. Local focus. Research-backed insight.

Research

The jobs boom healthcare already paid for

· Retrospective edition

Editorial artwork: The jobs boom healthcare already paid for

A boom that arrived with $4.14 gasoline

The Labor Day jobs report was written to be celebrated. U.S. employers added 162,000 payroll jobs in August, more than three times the 53,000 that had been penciled in, and the unemployment rate held at 4.1 percent. UBS promptly switched to expecting quarter-point rate increases in both September and December. Traders, via CME’s FedWatch, put the odds of a hike at the mid-September meeting around 58 percent. That is what a “strong” labor market is supposed to look like from a dealing desk.

It is not what it looks like from a pump. AAA put regular gasoline at a record Labor Day $4.14 a gallon and diesel at a record of its own. The White House talked about hiring. Drivers talked about the last summer trip they did not take. The useful question is not whether August printed a big number. It is whether the paycheck underneath that number had already stopped stretching.

The official books that can answer that question stop in July. The Current Employment Statistics extract used here is a 24 August 2026 snapshot, so it predates the September 4 revisions that turned July from a reported 23,000-job loss into a 21,000-job gain. August is not in the file. What the file does show, without any help from a holiday weekend, is that the labor market markets just re-rated was already a healthcare story with a stalled real wage.

The monthly job machine was already sputtering before August

Bar chart of monthly U.S. nonfarm payroll changes from 2024 through July 2026, showing small and sometimes negative months before the later August 2026 bounce.
Month-to-month change in seasonally adjusted nonfarm payrolls, thousands of jobs. July 2026 shows a 23,000-job decline in this 24 August 2026 snapshot — the figure later revised to a 21,000-job gain. Several 2025 months were already negative. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CES. Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics.
Download exact data
View exact chart values
monthtotal_nonfarm_change_thousandsfood_services_change_thousandslocal_gov_edu_change_thousandsmanufacturing_change_thousandsinformation_change_thousandsprivate_ed_health_change_thousands
2024-0220622.916.5-23-597
2024-0322819.531.6-16-795
2024-0464-18.3-7.2-3-1188
2024-0578-303.7-8-1070
2024-068712.2-20.5-11091
2024-07535.334.2-8-1341
2024-089-4.15.6-34-858
2024-0915525.82.4-14-6118
2024-10335.411.8-61-1695
2024-111343.1514-284
2024-1223726.98.3-181075
2025-01-48-29.110-20-1861
2025-0242-38.27.9-2-158
2025-036710.47.4-5-968
2025-0410813.55.1-4-284
2025-0513-4.44-11-160
2025-06-201.211.9-15-149
2025-07645.34.6-11-287
2025-08-70212.6-10-123
2025-097638.97-3-154
2025-10-14042.65.6-9-644
2025-114121.6-2-10-556
2025-12-17-4.8-5.8-13-638
2026-0116023.22.92-27119
2026-02-156-38.8-5.21-23-49
2026-0321427.51115195
2026-041484.9-11-1-667
2026-056324.9-26.1-2-524
2026-0620-12.1-11.611-1354
2026-07-23-26.1-49.651125

Nominal dollars kept rising. Real ones did not

Seasonally adjusted average hourly earnings for all private employees were $35.84 in January 2025 and $37.62 in July 2026, a 5.0 percent raise in the number on the stub. Deflate those same earnings the way the Bureau of Labor Statistics does — into 1982–84 dollars — and the picture flattens. Real average hourly earnings were $11.24 in January 2025. They peaked at $11.38 in November 2025 and again in January–February 2026, just as U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran began. By July they were $11.30, still 0.5 percent above the start of 2025 and 0.7 percent below February. June and July are preliminary.

That is not a collapse. It is a stall with a dip attached, arriving in the same months gasoline and diesel were setting records. The 2022 inflation scare had already shown how this series behaves: real hourly pay bottomed at $10.91 in June 2022, when the national gasoline average last made politicians sweat. The 2026 slip is smaller. It is also happening while officials describe the labor market as sturdy enough to tighten. A 5 percent nominal raise that buys 0.5 percent more after prices is not what “blew past forecasts” sounds like in a grocery aisle.

Hours did not rescue the paycheck. Average weekly hours for all private employees were 34.1 in January 2025 and 34.3 in July 2026. Restaurant cooks did not get there by working a hidden extra shift. Food-services hourly pay, available through June in this snapshot, rose from $20.95 to $21.99, about 5.0 percent — the same nominal pace as the private sector overall, from a much lower base, in the industry that accounted for most of August’s headline gain.

Real average hourly earnings have slipped since the Iran war began

Line chart of U.S. real average hourly earnings in 1982-84 dollars from 2019 through July 2026, peaking in late 2025 and early 2026 then declining after February 2026.
Seasonally adjusted average hourly earnings of all private employees, in 1982–84 dollars. The series is CPI-deflated by BLS. July 2026 is preliminary. October 2025 is missing from the extract (one null, not treated as zero). Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics, snapshot 24 August 2026. Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics.
Download exact data
View exact chart values
monthreal_ahe_1982_84_dollarsstatus
2019-0110.92
2019-0210.93
2019-0310.92
2019-0410.89
2019-0510.92
2019-0610.96
2019-0710.96
2019-0810.99
2019-0910.98
2019-1010.98
2019-1110.99
2019-1210.97
2020-0110.97
2020-0211.01
2020-0311.13
2020-0411.73
2020-0511.62
2020-0611.43
2020-0711.38
2020-0811.37
2020-0911.35
2020-1011.35
2020-1111.36
2020-1211.41
2021-0111.39
2021-0211.4
2021-0311.33
2021-0411.33
2021-0511.33
2021-0611.28
2021-0711.28
2021-0811.29
2021-0911.31
2021-1011.26
2021-1111.2
2021-1211.18
2022-0111.18
2022-0211.12
2022-0311.05
2022-0411.08
2022-0511.02
2022-0610.91
2022-0710.97
2022-0810.99
2022-0910.99
2022-1010.97
2022-1110.98
2022-1211.02
2023-0110.99
2023-0211
2023-0311.02
2023-0411.04
2023-0511.04
2023-0611.08
2023-0711.11
2023-0811.07
2023-0911.07
2023-1011.08
2023-1111.09
2023-1211.11
2024-0111.13
2024-0211.1
2024-0311.09
2024-0411.1
2024-0511.14
2024-0611.18
2024-0711.19
2024-0811.21
2024-0911.23
2024-1011.23
2024-1111.25
2024-1211.24
2025-0111.24
2025-0211.24
2025-0311.29
2025-0411.28
2025-0511.32
2025-0611.31
2025-0711.32
2025-0811.33
2025-0911.32
2025-1111.38
2025-1211.35
2026-0111.38
2026-0211.38
2026-0311.31
2026-0411.25
2026-0511.23
2026-0611.31footnote:P
2026-0711.3footnote:P

Nominal pay kept rising. Inflation-adjusted pay did not

Two-line chart comparing nominal and real average hourly earnings indexed to January 2025, with nominal rising to about 105 and real stalling near 100 by July 2026.
Indexes of seasonally adjusted average hourly earnings for all private employees, January 2025 = 100. Nominal earnings rose about 5 percent through July 2026; real (1982–84 dollar) earnings were only 0.5 percent above January 2025 and 0.7 percent below February 2026. October 2025 real earnings are unavailable. July 2026 is preliminary. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CES, snapshot 24 August 2026. Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics.
Download exact data
View exact chart values
monthnominal_index_jan2025nominal_ahe_dollarsreal_index_jan2025real_ahe_1982_84_dollars
2019-0176.9827.5997.1510.92
2019-0277.2627.6997.2410.93
2019-0377.4827.7797.1510.92
2019-0477.5427.7996.8910.89
2019-0577.7927.8897.1510.92
2019-0678.0427.9797.5110.96
2019-0778.2128.0397.5110.96
2019-0878.5228.1497.7810.99
2019-0978.5728.1697.6910.98
2019-1078.7928.2497.6910.98
2019-1179.0728.3497.7810.99
2019-1279.1928.3897.610.97
2020-0179.3228.4397.610.97
2020-0279.6328.5497.9511.01
2020-0380.1628.7399.0211.13
2020-0483.8230.04104.3611.73
2020-0582.9229.72103.3811.62
2020-0681.9829.38101.6911.43
2020-078229.39101.2511.38
2020-0882.2829.49101.1611.37
2020-0982.3429.51100.9811.35
2020-1082.4229.54100.9811.35
2020-1182.729.64101.0711.36
2020-1283.4529.91101.5111.41
2021-0183.5129.93101.3311.39
2021-0283.8430.05101.4211.4
2021-0383.7930.03100.811.33
2021-0484.3230.22100.811.33
2021-0584.8530.41100.811.33
2021-0685.2130.54100.3611.28
2021-0785.5530.66100.3611.28
2021-0885.8830.78100.4411.29
2021-0986.4430.98100.6211.31
2021-1086.8931.14100.1811.26
2021-1187.1431.2399.6411.2
2021-1287.5831.3999.4711.18
2022-0188.1731.699.4711.18
2022-0288.2831.6498.9311.12
2022-0388.7331.898.3111.05
2022-0489.1731.9698.5811.08
2022-0589.5632.198.0411.02
2022-0689.8232.1997.0610.91
2022-0790.2332.3497.610.97
2022-0890.5132.4497.7810.99
2022-0990.8832.5797.7810.99
2022-1091.2432.797.610.97
2022-1191.5732.8297.6910.98
2022-1291.9132.9498.0411.02
2023-0192.1333.0297.7810.99
2023-0292.4933.1597.8611
2023-0392.8333.2798.0411.02
2023-0493.2833.4398.2211.04
2023-0593.4733.598.2211.04
2023-069433.6998.5811.08
2023-0794.4533.8598.8411.11
2023-0894.5633.8998.4911.07
2023-0994.8934.0198.4911.07
2023-1095.0934.0898.5811.08
2023-1195.3434.1798.6711.09
2023-1295.6834.2998.8411.11
2024-0196.1834.4799.0211.13
2024-0296.3234.5298.7511.1
2024-0396.6834.6598.6711.09
2024-0496.9934.7698.7511.1
2024-0597.3534.8999.1111.14
2024-0697.6835.0199.4711.18
2024-0797.8835.0899.5611.19
2024-0898.2735.2299.7311.21
2024-0998.635.3499.9111.23
2024-1098.9435.4699.9111.23
2024-1199.3335.6100.0911.25
2024-1299.5835.6910011.24
2025-0110035.8410011.24
2025-02100.2835.9410011.24
2025-03100.7536.11100.4411.29
2025-04100.7836.12100.3611.28
2025-05101.2336.28100.7111.32
2025-06101.4536.36100.6211.31
2025-07101.7636.47100.7111.32
2025-08102.1836.62100.811.33
2025-09102.436.7100.7111.32
2025-10102.8236.85
2025-11103.2437101.2511.38
2025-12103.2937.02100.9811.35
2026-01103.6637.15101.2511.38
2026-02103.9937.27101.2511.38
2026-03104.2137.35100.6211.31
2026-04104.3837.41100.0911.25
2026-05104.637.4999.9111.23
2026-06104.9137.6100.6211.31
2026-07104.9737.62100.5311.3

Healthcare hired. Factories and information did not

Count the jobs, not the adjectives. From January 2025 through July 2026, total nonfarm payrolls rose by 590,000, or 0.37 percent — 158.3 million to 158.9 million. Private education and health services alone added 956,000 jobs, a 3.5 percent increase. That single supersector more than accounted for the entire net gain. Everyone else, taken together, shrank.

The split is not subtle. Manufacturing fell by 62,000 jobs, or 0.5 percent, to 12.61 million. Information, the payroll home of publishing, telecom, data processing and a good deal of the industry now promising artificial general intelligence, fell by 97,000 jobs, or 3.4 percent, to 2.78 million. Goods-producing employment as a whole was essentially unchanged, up 2,000 jobs on a base of 21.6 million. If the political argument is that tariffs and a tighter border would restock the factory floor, the factory floor had not noticed by July.

Food services and drinking places did add 111,000 jobs over those 18 months, a 0.9 percent rise. Leisure and hospitality, the broader grouping that includes restaurants, added 99,000. Those two figures cannot be stacked: restaurants sit inside leisure. Local government education, which the August report credited with 42,000 new jobs in a single month, was down 41,000 from January 2025 through July. August may well have been a bounce. It was bouncing off a decline.

Healthcare did the hiring. Factories and information did not

Horizontal bar chart ranking U.S. industries by job change from January 2025 to July 2026, led by private education and health services at plus 956 thousand and information at minus 97 thousand.
Change in seasonally adjusted payroll employment, January 2025 to July 2026, in thousands of jobs. Private education and health services added 956,000 jobs — more than the entire 590,000-job rise in total nonfarm payrolls. Manufacturing and information shrank. Figures are from the 24 August 2026 CES snapshot, so July 2026 is the unrevised preliminary estimate (later revised). Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics.
Download exact data
View exact chart values
industryjob_change_thousands
Private education and health services956
Food services and drinking places110.6
Leisure and hospitality99
Goods-producing2
Local government education-41.3
Manufacturing-62
Information-97

One sector carried the payroll. Several others went the other way

Multi-line index chart of U.S. payrolls since January 2025 showing private education and health rising, information falling, and manufacturing slightly down.
Payroll employment indexed to January 2025 = 100, seasonally adjusted. Private education and health services climbed to 103.5 by July 2026. Information fell to 96.6. Manufacturing drifted down. Food services rose modestly, then faded after January 2026. July 2026 is preliminary in this 24 August 2026 snapshot. Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, CES. Sources: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics.
Download exact data
View exact chart values
monthtotal_nonfarm_indextotal_nonfarm_thousandsfood_services_indexfood_services_thousandslocal_gov_education_indexlocal_gov_education_thousandsmanufacturing_indexmanufacturing_thousandsinformation_indexinformation_thousandsprivate_ed_health_indexprivate_ed_health_thousandsgoods_producing_indexgoods_producing_thousandsleisure_hospitality_indexleisure_hospitality_thousands
2024-0199.2215703299.6812196.698.768082.1101.5912875102.99296396.426033100.332163199.3116716
2024-0299.3515723899.8612219.598.968098.6101.4112852102.82295896.7626130100.272161799.4816744
2024-0399.49157466100.021223999.358130.2101.2912836102.57295197.1126225100.362163699.6916780
2024-0499.5315753099.8712220.799.268123101.2612833102.19294097.4326313100.332163199.5816762
2024-0599.5815760899.6312190.799.318126.7101.212825101.84293097.6926383100.312162599.416731
2024-0699.6415769599.7312202.999.068106.2101.1112814101.84293098.0326474100.332163099.4816744
2024-0799.6715774899.7712208.299.478140.4101.0512806101.39291798.1826515100.362163699.5216751
2024-0899.6815775799.7412204.199.548146100.7812772101.11290998.426573100.322162899.4916746
2024-0999.7815791299.9512229.999.578148.4100.6712758100.9290398.8326691100.352163499.6716776
2024-1099.815794599.9912235.399.728160.2100.1912697100.35288799.1926786100.12158199.816799
2024-1199.88158079100.0212238.499.788165.2100.312711100.28288599.526870100.22160299.9516823
2024-12100.03158316100.2412265.399.888173.5100.1612693100.63289599.7726945100.1521591100.1816862
2025-0110015826810012236.21008183.5100126731002877100270061002155910016832
2025-02100.0315831099.6912198100.18191.499.981267199.972876100.21270641002156099.7916796
2025-03100.0715837799.7712208.4100.198198.899.941266699.652867100.47271321002155999.9516823
2025-04100.1415848599.8812221.9100.258203.999.911266299.582865100.782721699.9821555100.0216836
2025-05100.1515849899.8512217.5100.38207.999.831265199.5528641012727699.921538100.0416839
2025-06100.1315847899.8612218.7100.448219.899.711263699.512863101.182732599.8121519100.0316837
2025-07100.1715854299.912224100.58224.499.621262599.442861101.52741299.7121496100.116848
2025-08100.13158472100.0712245100.53822799.541261599.412860101.592743599.5521461100.2316870
2025-09100.18158548100.3912283.9100.62823499.521261299.372859101.792748999.621472100.4516907
2025-10100.09158408100.7412326.5100.698239.699.451260399.172853101.952753399.521452100.6916948
2025-11100.11158449100.9112348.1100.668237.699.371259398.992848102.162758999.6221477100.6216936
2025-12100.1158432100.8812343.3100.598231.899.271258098.782842102.32762799.5221456100.7716961
2026-01100.2158592101.0612366.5100.638234.799.281258297.842815102.742774699.7321501100.816966
2026-02100.11158436100.7512327.7100.568229.599.291258397.052792102.562769799.6321480100.6116935
2026-03100.24158650100.9712355.2100.78240.599.411259897.082793102.912779299.7921513100.8716979
2026-04100.33158798101.0112360.1100.568229.599.41259796.872787103.162785999.8121519100.8316972
2026-05100.37158861101.2212385100.248203.499.381259596.72782103.252788399.8321522101.0817014
2026-06100.39158881101.1212372.9100.18191.899.471260696.252769103.452793799.8921536100.8316971
2026-07100.37158858100.912346.899.58142.299.511261196.632780103.5427962100.0121561100.5916931

What a rate hike would be reacting to

Index the same payrolls to January 2025 and the lines diverge in a way a single monthly print cannot hide. Private education and health services climb to 103.5 by July. Information slides to 96.6. Manufacturing drifts down and then sideways. Food services peak just after the new year and give some of it back. Total nonfarm barely makes it to 100.4. That is a labor market in which hospitals and clinics are still staffing up, software and media are still cutting, and the rest of the economy is close to treading water.

Month to month, the machine was already sputtering. In this vintage, total nonfarm payrolls fell in January, June, August, October and December 2025, and again in February and July 2026. Several of the plus months were smaller than a rounding error on a 159 million payroll. The September 4 revisions will have rewritten July. They will not have rewritten the 18-month arithmetic: net hiring was slow, concentrated, and already fading in real pay when the Iran war pushed energy costs back into the CPI.

None of this proves that $4 gasoline caused the real-wage dip, or that 162,000 August jobs were “fake,” or that the Federal Reserve should or should not hike. CES earnings are averages, not household budgets; a nurse’s raise and a cook’s raise are in the same mean. Food services is a slice of leisure, not a second helping. The extract is not the September 4 report. What it can say, without a speechwriter, is simpler. The boom traders just priced in was, through July, a healthcare boom. Real hourly pay had already stopped rising. The holiday-weekend gasoline line is what that feels like when you still have to drive to the shift.

Sources and methods

This is retrospective enrichment using a pinned CES snapshot, not a reconstruction of what was knowable on the 7 September 2026 edition date. Later releases and revisions may differ.

Research date: 11 September 2026. Historical edition date: 7 September 2026. Observation window: monthly CES series from January 2015 (earnings) or January 2019 (payrolls and hours) through July 2026. Product snapshot: bls-ce-snapshot-2026-08-24, created 24 August 2026, covering employment, hours and earnings through July 2026.

July 2026 values carry BLS preliminary status (footnote P) in this vintage. The snapshot predates the 4 September 2026 Employment Situation, which reported 162,000 August jobs and revised July from −23,000 to +21,000. August 2026 is therefore cited only from that day’s reporting, not from the extract.

Real average hourly earnings are BLS series CES0500000013 (all employees, total private, seasonally adjusted, 1982–84 dollars). Nominal earnings are CES0500000003. Payrolls are all-employees, thousands, seasonally adjusted. One real-earnings observation (October 2025) is null in the extract and is omitted, not treated as zero. No duplicate periods were found.

Industry totals are not additive across overlapping groups: food services and drinking places sit inside leisure and hospitality. Private education and health services is not the same as local government education. Changes are arithmetic differences in seasonally adjusted levels; they are not causal estimates of the Iran war, tariffs, or immigration policy. Averages are not household budgets. Scale is thousands of jobs for payrolls and dollars per hour for earnings.

Research completed 2026-09-11, for the September 7, 2026 news edition. This is retrospective analysis, not a reconstruction of information available that day.

  • U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Current Employment Statistics: Source 1, Source 2

Read the related National / Federal News edition →